The only way Runescape EoC can be added
You have to have:
1. Separate servers: This is a given, there's no reason to allow both styles of combat on the same server.
And one of A or B:
A. EoC is nerfed. This doesn't have to be in a complicated way, but could be something such as -50% xp, -50% drop chance in EoC worlds but the numbers are adjusted so it's somewhat balanced.
B. EoC is a completely separate save file, nothing from legacy mode transfers to EoC or vice versa.
Counterarguments:
"But if people really like Legacy so much, they wouldn't switch to playing EoC just to get more xp!":
- You can say exactly the same thing the other way. If you guys do like EoC so much, then you shouldn't care at all about XP/drops being nerfed. Afterall, you're having more fun playing EoC and apparently don't care about how much you progress.
"But Malza! The majority of the PvP playerbase vastly prefers EoC for some reason!"
-This is exactly why Oldschool Runescape is more popular than RS3 right? And Legacy PKing is more popular than EoC PKing on RS3.
Related News

Jan
Falador Massacre glitch
Old School Runescape is marking the 10-year anniversary of one of the all-time best MMO bugs: the Falador Massacre.

Nov
Runescape New Smuggling Skill
Since so many players dislike the current smuggling system, not due to the danger but rather due to the boredom and how it screws up quests, slayer and other game content. And there's no real reward for smuggling.

Mar
Treasure Hunter Flight of the Butterflies
To get involved, simply open Treasure Hunter to bring up Flight of the Butterflies. When you first log in you’ll be given a quick tutorial to explain the basics and how you can get involved.

Sep
The RuneScape Guide: Why "Glouphrie's" Hood?
I'm suggesting a new head-slot item be added to the game that slightly mimics the Wicked Hood

Sep
In Runescape EoC this will share cooldown with hurricane/quake
Hopefully with these changes, Shields will be more viable in PvM/PvP by making 1h weapons function similar to the way it did in Runescape Pre-EoC

Dec
My Beneath Cursed Tides review
The requirements for the quest include level 30 in several skills trained on the island. Thats fine but where the issue comes in is the lack of previously stated quest requirement.